La tunisie Medicale - 2017 ; Vol 95 ( n°012 ) : 229-235
[ Vu 115 fois ]
Résumé

Introduction:La gestion de la qualité de vie liée à la santé (QVLS) est de plus en plus considérée comme un objectif important de traitement dans les maladies chroniques y compris les maladies inflammatoires chroniques de l’intestin (MICI).
But : Le but de notre étude était de déterminer l’impact des MICI sur la QVLS des malades et identifier les facteurs intervenant dans l’altération de la QVLS de ces patients.
Méthodes : Nous avons mené une étude cas-témoins, incluant 108 patients : 66 maladies de Crohn(MC) et 42 Rectocolite hémorragique (RCH). Dans la mesure de la QVLS, on a utilisé un questionnaire général « Short Form 36 : SF36 » et un questionnaire spécifique « TunisianInflammatoryBowelDisease Questionnaire : T-IBDQ».
Résultats : La QVLS des patients était plus mauvaise que celle des témoins avec une différence statistiquement significative pour six des huit dimensions du SF 36 : "PF", " RP", "GH", "SF", "MH" et "RE", ainsi que le score résumé mental (MCS) et  le score résumé physique (PCS). Les facteurs intervenant dans l’altération de la QVLSétaient : l’âge < 30ans, les mauvaises conditions socioéconomiques, l’activité de la maladie, la corticothérapie, un nombre d’interventions chirurgicales >=2 et les antécédents d’hospitalisation(s) antérieure(s).Conclusion :On a démontré que les MICI, aussi bien la MC que la RCHentraînent une altération de la QVLS objectivée par la diminution des scores du SF 36 par rapport aux témoins et touchant presque tous les domaines du SF 36. Les facteurs incriminés peuvent être liés au malade, à la maladie et même au traitement.

Mots Clés
Article

INTRODUCTION :
Quality of life (QOL) is a subjective and quantitative measurement of individual perception of health status. It includes not only the physical side, but also the emotional and social side of the disease (1). Unlike the QOL where factors other than those relating to health are involved, health-related quality of life (HRQL) is interested in the end result of medical action and is, hence, an indicator of choice of the efficiency of medical care. This concept of HRQL is both recent and very present in the current scientific literature (2). The evaluation by physicians can no longer be only based on biomedical criteria. It is important to assess how "should feel" the patient on objective criteria, but also how he "sees" actually on subjective criteria. This is especially interesting to consider for chronic conditions such as Inflammatory bowel disease (IBD): Crohn's disease (CD) and ulcerative colitis (UC) that are a good illustration since they are debilitating chronic diseases, affecting young adults. The different index measuring the clinical activity of IBD do not appreciate the illness experience, ability to work and the emotional and social functions. Only the use of QOL scales allows the physician to understand the patient as a whole, beyond the only organ dysfunctions. The aim of our study is to determine the impact of IBD on HRQL of patients and to identify factors impairing QOL in these patients.
METHODS :
It is a case-control study including patients with IBD who presented to the consultation or who were hospitalized at Gastroenterology department ofSahloulUniversity Hospital, Sousse between September 2015 and November 2015. The diagnosis of IBD was based on clinical, endoscopic, radiological and histological data. Informed oral consent of the nature and purpose of the study was obtained from all patients. The controls subjects were collected from the medical and paramedical staff who do not have IBD.
MesuringHRQL :
We used in this study two questionnaires validated in Arabic on the Tunisian population: A general questionnaire for patients and controls; the "Survey Short form 36 (SF-36)" (3) and a specific questionnaire IBD "T-IBDQ" for patients (4).
Short form Survey 36 « SF 36 » :
The SF-36 is a generic scale that measures HRQL. This is an Anglo-Saxon  questionnaire containing initially 149 items designed in 1986 from an observational study of "Medical Outcome Study" (MOS) including 2546 patients (5). The initial questionnaire was then reduced to a simplified version of "Short Form" (SF) containing 36 items. In evaluation of HRQL, SF-36 is currently considered "gold standard" thanks to its concision, its high reproducibility, validity and sensitivity to change. The simplified questionnaire contains 36 items grouped in nine dimensions: Physical Functionning (PF), Role physical (RP), Bodily Pain (BP), General Health (GH), Vitality (VT), Social Functionning (SF), Mental Health (MH), Role Emotional (RE), and Health Transition(HT). Several items are grouped to form the score of each dimension between 0 (worst quality) and 100 (highest quality) for each of the 9 dimensions. The first 4 dimensions are synthesized in a Physical Summary (Score PCS) and the following four dimensions in a Mental Summary Score (MCS). Health Transition does not belong in the summary scores. In our study, we used the translated version in Arabic and validated on a Tunisian population (3). The majority of subjects responded to questions by themselves. Illiterate subjects were interviewed by the same person in order to minimize the risk of error. The transformation of the 36 questions in 9 dimensions was made online through the algorithm published in the SF interpretation manual guide 36. The html website address used is as follows:http://www.sf-36.org/demos/SF-36.html.
Inflammatory bowel disease questionnaire « IBDQ » :
Several quality of life assessment questionnaires were designed speciallyfor patients with IBD. The most used worldwide is "The Inflammatory Bowel Disease Questionnaire" (IBDQ) thanks to its performance and demonstrated good psychometric properties (6). It was designed in 1989 by Guyatt et al and validated initially on a Canadian cohort (7). Its use increasingly frequent in clinical trials around the world imposed its translation into various languages and adaptation to different cultures (8). Translated version in Tunisian dialect Arabic was published in 2013. This version contained 30 items divided into 5 areas: Digestive symptoms I (SDI), digestive symptoms II (SDII), systemic signs (SS), emotional disorders (ED) and social Function (SF). Each question is scored according to the number of proposals from 1 (very serious problem) to 4 or 5 (no problem at all). The final score ranges from 30 to 123. The higher the score is, better is quality of life (4).
Statistical analysis :

Data was analyzed using SPSS Version 20. The comparison of  2averages was performed using the Student t test for independent samples or ANOVA test to one factor. The comparison of percentages was performed by the Khi-square test of Pearson, and in case of non-validity, the Fisher exact test. The correlation between two quantitative variables was studied using the Pearson correlation coefficient. The significance level was set at 0.05.
RESULTS :
Characteristics of patients and controls :
One hundred and eight patients with IBD and 108 controls were included during the study period. The average age of patients was 37.6 years (range 15-70 years). The patients were divided into 61 women and 47 men with a sex ratio (female / male) equal to 1.29. The socio-demographic characteristics of patients and controls are shown in Table 1.
Comparison of quality of life by the  SF36 between patients and controls:
In univariate analysis, comparison of HRQL by the SF-36 between patients and controls  showed that the scores of all dimensions were lower in patients with a statistically significant difference for the dimensions "Physical Functionning PF" (p = 0.001), "Role Physical RP" (p = 0.001), "General Health GH" (p <0.001), "Social Functionning SF" (p <0.001) "Mental Health MH" (p <0.001), "Role Emotional RE" (p = 0.032), "Health Transition HT" (p <0.001) and for the "Physical summury score" PCS (p = 0.005) and "the Mental summary score" MCS (p <0.001). For the remaining two dimensions "Bodily Pain BP" and "Vitality VT ', scores were comparable between cases and controls (Figure 1).
In multivariate analysis, the IBD status was associated with impaired HRQOL for six dimensions of the SF 36 "Physical Function PF", "Role Physical RP," "General Health GH "," Social Functionning SF "," Mental Health MH "and" Role Emotional RE "as well as Physical summary score (PCS) and Mental summary score (MCS), independently of other factors by which the two groups differed (table 2).
Comparison of T-IBDQ and SF36:
A statistically significant correlation was found between the total score of the T-IBDQ with its various areas and all dimensions of SF 36. In fact, the correlation coefficient "r" was constantly positive with p<0.05 (table 3), which means that over the values of the global score of the T-IBDQ and its areas were high, the scores of dimensions of SF 36, the PhysicalSummury Score and Mental Summary Score were also high.
Factors influencing the HRQoL of patients with IBD:
Factors related to patient :
The correlation between the general and specific questionnaires allowed to us to study the factors influencing the HRQL of patients based on "T-IBDQ" scores.
Elderly patients over 30 years had higher scores of T-IBDQ with a statistically significant difference for the field "emotional disorders" (p = 0.045). Indeed, patients aged under 30 years had more emotional problems such as frustration, depression and anxiety. Scores of T-IBDQ and its areas were lower in patients with poor socio-economic conditions with a statistically significant difference for the total score of T-IBDQ, "emotional disorders" and "social function". There was no difference in scores of T-IBDQ and its areas based on gender, marital status, educational level, employment status, smoking, presence of personal medico surgical history and family history of IBD (table 4).
Factors related to the disease:
The total score of the T-IBDQ and its areas were compared between the three groups of patients: patients in remission or with minimal activity, patients with moderate activity,  and those with severe activity or having a complication. This analysis showed that more IBD was active, the scores of of T-IBDQ and its areas were low. However, the scores ofthe five areas of the T-IBDQ were comparable between patients, whatever the type of IBD, disease extent, duration of evolution, the number of previous outbreaks , duration of remission, the presence of ano-perineal lesions, and extra digestive manifestations.The total score of T-IBD and scores of its domains "digestive symptoms I" and "social function" were statistically lower in patients with oral corticosteroids. However, the different scores were comparable between patients treated and those not treated with sulfapyridine, 5 ASA, the thiopurines, infliximab or adalimumab. The scores of different areas were identical in patients operated and other patients. The scores of patients who underwent two surgeries were lower than those with a single intervention, with a statistically significant difference for the area "digestive symptoms II" related to abdominal pain, abdominal bloating and difficulty in emission of gases (p = 0.008). Patients who have been hospitalized previously had lower scores with a statistically significant difference for the field "social function" (p = 0.05). But the number of hospitalizations did not influence the quality of life in these patients (Table 5).
Thus, the factors involved in the deterioration of HRQL in our study were: age <30 years, poor economic conditions, the activity of the disease, taking steroids and a number of surgeries> = 2 (Figure 2).


DISCUSSION :
Our study is the first one that has assessed HRQOL in patients with IBD using the Arabic version of the two questionnaires validated in Tunisia: the SF-36 and T-IBDQ. The scores of the eight dimensions of the SF36 were lower than control group with a statistically significant difference in six dimensions. This alteration of HRQOL in patients with IBD was also found in several studies (9, 10, 11). In fact, Bernklev and al. had compared HRQOL of 514 patients (166 CD, 348 UC) to a control group (2323 healthy subjects). In this study, the scores of the 6 dimensions of the SF 36 from 8 in ulcerative colitis and 7 dimensions on 8 in CD were significantly lower in patients than in controls (9). Bastida and al. Had shown that 8 dimensions of the SF 36 were significantly lower in patients with IBD (68 CD, 24 UC) compared to the general population (10). In an European cohort study including 769 patients (517 UC, 252 CD), 7 dimensions among  8 dimensions of the SF-36 were reduced compared to the general population. The scores of the dimension MH "mental health" were lower in case of Crohn's disease (11). In contrast to these studies, Anderson and al. showed that there was no significant difference in scores of SF-36 between patients with CD in remission and controls (12).
In our study, a statistically significant correlation was found between the total score of the T-IBDQ with its various fields and all dimensions of SF 36. This was demonstrated in several studies (13, 14). In a Chinese study, Ren et al. compared the scores of areas of IBDQ to the dimensions of SF 36 scores in 92 patients (40 CD, 52 UC). A statistically significant correlation was observed with a correlation coefficient Pearson r ranging between 0.51 and 0.82 (13).In a Greek study, Pallis et al. have shown a strong correlation between the scores of the SF 36 IBDQ and in a population of 114 patients (45 CD, 69 UC) (14).
As well as our results, Rubin et al. (15) and Saibeni et al. (16) have found that younger patients had lower HRQOL. Other authors demonstrated that age was inversely related to HRQL scores (17, 18). This can be explained on the one hand to the increase in the incidence of co-morbidities associated with IBD and secondly to the own morbidity age. In most studies, the female  genderwas found as a factor significantly associated with impaired HRQoL (19, 20). Several hypotheses for this finding are frequently reported in these studies. Psychosocial factors may play a more important role in women than in men. In fact, women have larger concerns about the disease and its impact on body image. Some authors have found that scores of IBDQ were significantly lower in patients with poor material conditions (15, 21). Other studies have shown a positive correlation between the level of university studies and HRQL (17, 19). This relationship may be due to better socio-economic level inthis group of patients. Indeed, subjects with a high educational level have easier access to information concerning their disease. However, uneducated patients with lack of information about their pathology hasmore concerns about their disease and are unable to develop adaptive strategies (18).In most published series, the activity of IBD was the most consistently correlated factor to HRQL. In the meta-analysis of Van der Have M. et al. a correlation between alteration of HRQL and IBD activity, especially in CD, has been demonstrated in 10 studies (22).Several authors have reported a negative association between glucocorticoid therapy and HRQOL (11, 23). The side effects of steroids cosmetic, sleep disorders and mood were responsible for impaired HRQOL in these patients (23). Moreover, in most studies, corticosteroid therapy was not an independent factor responsible for impaired HRQOL because it is confused with disease activity. Rather, improving HRQOL with biotherapy type infliximab and adalimumab was reported in large clinical trials (24, 25),this was not observed in our study, probably because the number of patients under biotherapy was low. Even in the era of biologics, the need for surgery in IBD remains high (26). In the study of Agostini A. et al. including 103 patients (70 and CD, 33 UC), of which 37 were operated (ileal resection in 37 cases and colectomy in 10 cases), surgery was predictive of impaired QOL and particularly mental health ( p<0.005) (27). However, EK Wright et al. demonstrated in a study of 133 patients with CD who have had an ileocecal resection, a significant improvement in HRQOL observed at 6 months after surgery (p <0.001) and that this improvement was sustained and maintained 12 months and 18 months postoperatively (28).
CONCLUSION :
In our study, we found that IBD, as well as  CD and UC, had a considerable impact on HRQOL affecting all areas: physical, emotional, sexual, professional and social. Since HRQL is directly correlated to the disease activity, medical treatment must focus to control intestinal inflammation to achieve clinical, endoscopic and histological remission, even allowing the patient to have a better quality of life. The effectiveness of treatment should be evaluated not only on the basis of clinical disease activity but also on the basis of quality of life tools. In Tunisia, the management of IBD patients must appeal to the specific questionnaire in its Tunisian version. However, national studies on a larger scale would be necessary to make the use of HRQOL measurement tools in these patients in common practice in Tunisia.

Références
  1. Word Health Organization Quality Of Life Group. Study protocol for the World Health Organisation project to develop a quality of life assessment instrument (WHOQOL). Qual Life Res 1993;2:153–9.
  2. Testa MA, Simonson DC et al. Assessment of quality of life outcomes. New Engl J Med 1996;334:835-40.
  3. Guermazi M, Allouch C, Yahia M et al. Translation in Arabic, adaptation and validation of the SF-36 Health Survey for use in Tunisia. Annals of Physical and Rehabilitation Medicine 2012; 55: 388-403.
  4. Mnif L, Medhioub M, Boudabbous M et al. Validation de la version tunisienne du questionnaire de la qualité de vie dans les maladies inflammatoires chroniques de l'intestin. LA TUNISIE MEDICALE 2013 ; 91 (12) : 685-692.
  5. Wade JE, Sherbourne CD et al. The MOS 36-item short-form health survey (SF-36). Medical Care 1992;30:473–83.
  6. Cheung WY, Garratt AM, Russell IT, Williams JG. The UK IBDQ-a British version of the inflammatory bowel disease questionnaire. development and validation. J Clin Epidemiol. 2000;53(3):297-306.
  7. Guyatt G, Mitchell A, Irvine EJ et al. A new measure of health status for clinical trials in inflammatory bowel disease. Gastroenterology 1989;96:804 –10.
  8. Pallis A.G, Mouzas I.A, Vlachonikolis IG. The inflammatory bowel disease questionnaire : a review of its national validation studies . InflammBowel Dis 2004 ; 10 (3):261-69.
  9. Bernklev T, Jahnsen J, Lygren I. Health-related quality of life in patients with inflammatory bowel disease measured with the short form-36: psychometric assessments and comparison with general population norms. InflammBowel Dis 2005;11:909-18.
  10. Bastida G, Nos P, Aguas M. The effects of thiopurine therapy on health-related quality of life in Inflammatory Bowel Disease patients. Gastroenterology 2010;10:26.
  11. Gert Huppertz-HaussMD, Langholz E, Selwyn O et al. Health-related Quality of Life in Inflammatory Bowel Disease in a European-wide Population-based Cohort 10 Years After Diagnosis. InflammBowel Dis 2015;21:337–344.
  12. Andersson P, Olaison G, Bendtsen P. Health related quality of life in Crohn's proctocolitis does not differ from a general population when in remission. Colorectal Dis 2003;5:56-62.
  13. Ren WH, Lai M, Chen Y. Validation of the mainland chinese version of the inflammatory bowel disease questionnaire (IBDQ) for ulcerative colitis and Crohn’s disease. Inflamm Bowel Dis 2007;13:903-10.
  14. Pallis AG, Vlachonikollis IG, Mouzas IA. Quality of life of Greek patients with inflammatory bowel disease. Validation of the Greek translation of the inflammatory bowel disease questionnaire. Digestion 2001; 63: 240-6.
  15. Rubin GP, Hungin APS, Chinn DJ. Quality of life in patients with established inflammatory bowel disease: a UK general practice survey. Aliment PharmacolTher 2004;19:529–35.
  16. Saibeni S, Cortinovis I, Beretta L. Gender and disease activity influence health-related quality of life in inflammatory bowel diseases. Hepatogastroenterology 2005;52:509-15.
  17. J. Burisch, P.Weimersa, N. Pedersen et al.Health-related quality of life improves during one year of medical and surgical treatment in a European population-based inception cohort of patients with Inflammatory Bowel Disease.Journal of Crohn's and Colitis 2014; 8:1030–1042
  18. Iglesias M, Vázquez I, Barreiro de Acosta M. Health related quality of life in patients with Cohn´s disease in remission. Rev Esp EnfermDig 2010;102:624-30.
  19. LÓpez Blanco B, Moreno-Jiménez B, DevesaMúgica JM. Relationship between socio-demographic and clinical variables, and health-related quality of life in patients with inflammatory bowel disease. Rev Esp EnfermDig 2005;97:887-98.
  20. J. Magalhaes, FD. Castro, P. Carvalho, S. Leite, MJ. Moreira, J Cotter. Quality of life in patients with inflammatory bowel disease: importance of clinical, demographic and psychosocial factors. ArqGastroenterol 2014;51:192-7.
  21. Mnif L, Mzid A, Amouri A, Chtourou L, Tahri N. Health – related quality of life in patients with inflammatory bowel disease: a Tunisian study. TunisMed- 2010 ;88: 933-6.
  22. Van der Have M, van der Aalst KS, Kaptein AA, et al. Determinants of health-related quality of life in Crohn’s disease: A systematic review and meta-analysis. J CrohnsColitis 2014;8:93-106.
  23. Kuriyama M, Kato J, Kuwaki K. Clinical factors that impair health-related quality of life in ulcerative colitis patients vary with the disease duration. Eur J GastroenterolHepatol 2008;20:634-41.
  24. Feagan BG, Yan S, Bala M, et al. The effects of infliximab maintenance therapy on health-related quality of life. Am J Gastroenterol 2003;98:2232–2238
  25. Loftus EV, Feagan BG, Colombel JF, et al. Effects of adalimumab maintenance therapy on health related quality of life of patients with Crohn’s disease: patientreported outcomes of the CHARM trial. Am J Gastroenterol 2008;103:3132–3141.
  26. Caprilli R, Gassull MA, Escher JC, et al. European evidence based consensus on the diagnosis and management of Crohn’s disease: special situations. Gut 2006;55 :36–58.
  27. Agostini A, Moretti M, Calabrese C et al.Attachment and quality of life in patients with inflammatory bowel disease. Int J Colorectal Dis 2014;29:1291–1296.
  28. Wright EK,Kamm M, CruzP. Effect of Intestinal Resection on Quality of Life in Crohn’s Disease. Journal of Crohn's and Colitis 2015, 452–462.
Espace membre
E-mail :
Mot passe :
Mémoriser Mot de passe oublié S'inscrire
Archives
2018
Janvier
Février
Mars
Avril
Mai
Juin
Juillet
Août
Septembre
Octobre
Novembre
Décembre
Mots-clés
Enfant traitement pronostic Chirurgie diagnostic Tunisie Maladie de crohn Cancer dépistage Cancer du sein Coelioscopie Immunohistochimie prévention échographie mammographie
Newsletter
S'inscrire pour recevoir les newsletters
E-mail :
Partagez
Rejoignez-nous !